a change is just around the corner

///--->>>rethinking art, contemporaneity and (my)self

Works and Curations

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Has Contemporary Indian Art Become Too Comfortable?

, 

I have almost stopped looking at contemporary art. A rather embarrassing admission for someone who has spent a substantial part of his life looking at art, writing about it, working with artists, and occasionally curating exhibitions, but I increasingly find myself walking through galleries, museums, art fairs, and biennales with a peculiar sense of intellectual exhaustion, surrounded by impeccably installed objects, elaborate curatorial propositions, and the reassuring vocabulary of political engagement, while struggling to remain interested in what is being presented. Contemporary art exhibitions have begun to put me to sleep, which is especially unfortunate considering how much extraordinary artistic work continues to be produced across India, and how enthusiastically our cultural institutions insist that we are living through a moment of unprecedented artistic experimentation.

And just when I thought contemporary Indian art had exhausted its capacity to surprise me, Karan Johar was announced as the Cultural Ambassador of Art Mumbai 2026. I must admit, I laughed. The man who has spent decades perfecting the aesthetics of aspiration, glamour, and spectacular consumption had arrived to represent an art world that spends an extraordinary amount of time discussing resistance, marginality, and the politics of representation. Perhaps the appointment was more intellectually revealing than the organisers intended. We have reached a curious moment when contemporary art can speak endlessly about dismantling structures of power while becoming increasingly comfortable within the machinery of celebrity and luxury. Johar, at least, has always been rather candid about the spectacle he produces.

And perhaps that is precisely what has been troubling me. I have encountered artists in their studios whose practices are far more complicated, unpredictable, and politically charged than their public exhibitions suggest, where an unfinished experiment, a material accident, an unresolved question, or a conversation that wanders unexpectedly into the politics of everyday life can reveal an intellectual world considerably richer than the one eventually presented to the public. Yet somewhere between the studio and the gallery, something peculiar happens. The work acquires an extraordinarily coherent narrative, its contradictions are carefully organised, its political urgency is transformed into an elegant visual proposition, and the artist's restless engagement with the world becomes a perfectly articulated curatorial statement.

The politics remains in the vocabulary, but discomfort disappears from the encounter.

The Curious Business of Making Dissent Comfortable

Birender Yadav with Only the Earth Knows Their Labour at the Kochi Muziris Biennale (Kochi Biennale Foundation)

I have been thinking about this transformation for some time, particularly because contemporary Indian art has developed an extraordinary capacity to represent political concerns while remaining remarkably comfortable within the institutions that make such representations visible. An artist can investigate caste violence, ecological collapse, religious majoritarianism, gendered labour, dispossession, or the politics of memory, and the resulting work can enter a gallery as an expensive, impeccably lit object, accompanied by a curatorial statement that describes its political concerns with considerable sophistication while leaving the economic and institutional conditions of its exhibition entirely undisturbed.

Everything appears to be in place. The appropriate theoretical references, the material sophistication, the politically conscious language, the reassuring suggestion that we are encountering something urgent, and yet the urgency has somehow evaporated, leaving behind an exhibition that knows exactly how to look critical without necessarily producing a critical encounter.

I find myself increasingly interested in the distinction between what the artwork actually does, what the artist intends, what the curator proposes, what the institution permits, and what the collector eventually takes home, because these are different moments in the cultural life of an artwork, and the relationships between them deserve considerably more attention than they usually receive. The artwork might emerge from a difficult engagement with social reality, but its institutional presentation can reorganise that engagement into something more coherent, more recognisable, and considerably easier to consume.

I would also resist the temptation to equate decoration with intellectual weakness, particularly in a country where textiles, ornament, miniature painting, ritual objects, and vernacular visual cultures have carried extraordinarily complicated histories of labour, knowledge, and political representation. The decorative has its own intellectual traditions, and the modernist suspicion of ornament has already produced enough distortions in the writing of Indian art history. What troubles me is something more specific: the conversion of artistic complexity into easily consumable cultural sophistication, where even an aggressively political artwork can become a decorative confirmation of the viewer's existing intellectual and moral position.

The Curatorial Imagination and the Politics of Interpretation

Shailesh B.R. | New Moon NSIC Exhibition Grounds, Okhla, New Delhi, 5 - 8 February 2026| Vadhera Art Gallery


As someone who occasionally works as a curator, I find this particularly troubling because curatorial practice has always involved interpretation, selection, juxtaposition, and the production of meaning, and some of the most consequential exhibitions in art history have demonstrated how an artwork can acquire new political significance when placed within an unexpected historical, social, or institutional relationship. A curatorial proposition can politicise an artwork, repoliticise a historical object, reveal relationships that were previously invisible, or place familiar artistic practices within contexts that fundamentally change how we understand them, and this capacity to produce new relationships between artworks, histories, institutions, and audiences remains one of the most compelling possibilities of exhibition-making.

Which makes the current situation all the more disappointing, because I am increasingly encountering the opposite process. Rather than politicising the work, curatorial practice seems remarkably adept at depoliticising it, even while retaining the language of political engagement, so that the exhibition acknowledges the artist's concerns, identifies the appropriate historical references, translates the work into an intellectually respectable proposition, and quietly abandons the relationships that might make the work genuinely uncomfortable.

This is a curious kind of depoliticisation because it rarely requires the removal of political content. The political content remains conspicuously present, sometimes becoming the exhibition's principal attraction, while the relationships between that content and the conditions through which it is encountered remain conveniently unexplored. An artwork concerned with labour becomes an elegant installation, while the labour involved in producing the exhibition remains invisible; a work investigating caste becomes part of a prestigious institutional programme without necessarily prompting an examination of the social organisation of cultural authority; an ecological intervention becomes a centrepiece of cultural tourism, its critique of extraction absorbed into the spectacle of the event itself.

The curator has the capacity to expose these contradictions, to make them central to the exhibition, and to complicate the audience's relationship with the institution, but when curatorial practice instead resolves them into a coherent and comfortable narrative, something politically significant is lost.

. Prabhakar Kamble — Babasaheb with Labours (2022)| India Art Fair

The situation becomes more complicated as the boundaries between curatorial practice, gallery representation, and commercial mediation grow increasingly blurred, particularly when the same institution selects the artists, determines their public representation, constructs the interpretative framework, negotiates their commercial circulation, and claims curatorial authority over the resulting exhibition. Commercial galleries have produced intellectually significant exhibitions, and several Indian galleries have supported difficult artistic practices for decades, but the overlap between curatorial interpretation and commercial interest deserves closer scrutiny when the politics of an artwork must also accommodate the conditions through which that artwork becomes desirable, collectable, and institutionally prestigious.

The question concerns what happens to interpretation when the curator becomes increasingly responsible for producing a coherent cultural experience, rather than allowing the work to generate difficult and sometimes contradictory relationships with the world around it.

The Biennale and Its Contradictions

Biraaj Dodiya — DOOM ORGAN (2025), ASPINWALL HOUSE, KOCHI-MUZIRIS BIENNALE (KMB) 2025-26


The Kochi-Muziris Biennale offers a particularly interesting opportunity to examine these questions because its emergence transformed the geography of contemporary Indian art, creating an international exhibition platform outside the familiar metropolitan centres of Delhi and Mumbai while bringing artistic practices into dialogue with the layered histories, architecture, and material conditions of Kochi. Its sixth edition, For the Time Being, brought together artists and collectives through a curatorial framework concerned with temporality, collective experience, and forms of artistic engagement extending beyond the conventional exhibition object, propositions that have considerable intellectual possibilities in a country where artistic practices have long moved between formal institutions, public space, collective activity, and the social circumstances of everyday life.

Artists such as Birender Yadav and Prabhakar Kamble complicate any suggestion that contemporary Indian art has stopped producing politically engaged or intellectually challenging work, because their practices emerge from sustained engagements with the material and social conditions of Indian life rather than from the convenient adoption of a fashionable critical vocabulary. Yadav's investigations into brick-kiln labour, migrant workers, and the material economies of construction raise questions about extraction, embodied knowledge, and the labour that produces the architecture of contemporary prosperity, while Kamble's engagement with caste, everyday objects, labour, and Ambedkarite thought asks difficult questions about who produces cultural meaning and whose experiences remain invisible within established systems of representation.

Yet these practices also bring me back to the question that interests me most. What happens when an artwork about the invisibility of labour becomes an attraction within a large cultural event whose own labour arrangements, production economies, and institutional hierarchies deserve scrutiny, and how might the exhibition make those relationships visible rather than allowing the artwork's political concerns to remain safely contained within its curatorial description?

The contradiction requires investigation through the actual conditions of exhibition-making, because the presence of political art does not automatically produce a politically engaged exhibition, just as the presence of an ambitious curatorial statement does not guarantee that the resulting encounters will be intellectually demanding. A biennale can create genuinely new forms of artistic participation while also reproducing institutional hierarchies, and a politically ambitious curatorial proposition can produce encounters whose implications exceed the intentions of the curator, which is precisely why the distance between an artist's practice and its institutional presentation deserves to be examined rather than resolved through convenient generalisations.

I find myself wondering whether the spectacular expansion of the biennale as a cultural format has also produced a peculiar expectation that political engagement must become publicly visible through increasingly elaborate exhibition experiences, where the scale of the installation, the sophistication of the curatorial language, and the historical significance of the venue begin to compete with the questions that originally animated the work.

The artwork becomes part of an event, the event becomes part of a city's cultural identity, and the city's cultural identity becomes part of an economy of tourism, patronage, and international recognition, while the political concerns of the artist continue to circulate through the exhibition's publicity as evidence of its intellectual seriousness.

The Expanding Economy of Cultural Sophistication

Shiraz Bayjoo — Sa Sime Lamer (2025), Aspinwall House, Kochi-Muziris Biennale

The contemporary Indian art economy is expanding, and the evidence is increasingly visible in the growing scale of art fairs, the professionalisation of gallery representation, the emergence of private museums and foundations, and the proliferation of exhibition programmes that position contemporary art within a wider economy of cultural consumption. Art Mumbai's November 2026 edition brought together 94 Indian and international galleries at the Mahalaxmi Racecourse, alongside a sculpture park, performances, workshops, and an extensive programme of public conversations, while India Art Fair continues to attract galleries, collectors, institutions, and audiences into an increasingly sophisticated network of artistic visibility.

There is more money, more professionalisation, more elaborate exhibition-making, and greater international participation, but whether this expansion has produced a corresponding growth in curatorial independence and intellectual risk is another question altogether.

The collector's drawing room has always influenced artistic production, and the relationship between patronage and art has never been innocent, but I am increasingly interested in whether contemporary curatorial practice has begun to internalise the expectations of that drawing room even when its intellectual language continues to insist upon radicality, experimentation, and political engagement. The artwork must remain sufficiently challenging to acquire cultural distinction, sufficiently legible to circulate through institutional narratives, and sufficiently desirable to enter collections, producing a peculiar negotiation in which the appearance of intellectual difficulty can become an important part of its commercial attraction.

This is particularly interesting in relation to the established galleries that have shaped contemporary Indian art, including Nature Morte, Chemould Prescott Road, Sakshi, Gallery Espace, Experimenter, and Project 88, whose histories include substantial contributions to the development and international visibility of artistic practices that might otherwise have remained marginal. Their different trajectories deserve careful attention, because the relationship between commercial representation and curatorial ambition is considerably more complicated than a simple accusation of market corruption, and some of the most intellectually adventurous exhibitions in India have emerged from precisely these spaces.

Yet I would like to examine how individual practices are selected, edited, interpreted, and presented within such institutions, particularly when an artist's larger body of work contains contradictions, experiments, and unresolved questions that do not necessarily fit the coherent identity through which the artist becomes publicly recognisable. Which works become prominent, which aspects of the practice are repeatedly emphasised, which material experiments disappear from the exhibition, and how does the curatorial narrative begin to shape what audiences and collectors understand the artist to represent?

The emerging biennale circuit raises related questions through different institutional arrangements, particularly when exhibitions claim to engage with ecological materials, indigenous knowledge, local communities, and forms of cultural participation outside conventional metropolitan structures. Such commitments deserve serious attention, but so do the relationships through which they are realised, including who controls the interpretation of local knowledge, how the benefits of cultural participation are distributed, and what remains with communities after the exhibition has concluded and the international cultural audience has moved elsewhere.

I am particularly suspicious of the ease with which terms such as community, participation, and decoloniality can enter curatorial language without requiring institutions to examine their own authority over the people, materials, and histories they represent.

The politics of an exhibition cannot be assessed solely through the subjects it represents. Its relationships with people, materials, institutions, and economies are equally significant, and the failure to examine those relationships allows the exhibition to claim political seriousness while remaining remarkably insulated from the implications of its own propositions.

The Aestheticisation of Dissent

Sanchayan Ghosh | A Site for the Pedagogy of Resistance | Install view | Drawn from Practice II | Experimenter – Ballygunge Place, Kolkata | April 14 – June 30, 2022

I suspect several processes are operating simultaneously within contemporary curatorial culture, and one of the most conspicuous is the aestheticisation of dissent, where political content becomes an increasingly recognisable visual genre and the viewer encounters a familiar vocabulary of criticality long before encountering the particular questions that animate an individual work. Broken architecture signifies displacement, archival photographs signify memory, discarded objects signify ecological crisis, handmade textiles signify labour or indigenous knowledge, and the carefully arranged residue of a performance signifies the political possibilities of an event that has already taken place.

Every one of these strategies can produce extraordinary art, and many have substantial histories of experimentation and resistance, yet their repetition can also make them reassuringly familiar, particularly when the exhibition supplies an interpretative framework that confirms what the viewer already expects to discover.

The experienced visitor enters the gallery already knowing how to read its politics. The curator supplies the appropriate vocabulary, the installation confirms the proposition, and the audience experiences the satisfaction of having encountered something politically significant, even when the encounter has done relatively little to complicate its understanding of the world.

The professionalisation of curatorial language contributes to this process, particularly through the circulation of terms such as liminality, resilience, belonging, memory, ecology, and decoloniality, each carrying legitimate intellectual histories but increasingly capable of describing dozens of materially and politically distinct artistic practices with almost interchangeable results. When the same vocabulary can travel so effortlessly between exhibitions, artists, and institutions, I begin to wonder whether the writing is actually interpreting the work or merely locating it within an already established economy of cultural sophistication.

I have nothing against theory, and would prefer considerably more rigorous theoretical engagement in contemporary Indian art, but the substitution of theoretical vocabulary for theoretical work has become an exhausting habit, where the presence of an intellectual reference is treated as sufficient evidence that an exhibition has undertaken the difficult labour of thinking through its implications.

Another process concerns the domestication of conceptual and process-based art, particularly when an artwork begins as an intervention into public life, a collective experiment, an extended performance, or a process of social inquiry, and subsequently enters the gallery through its documentation, sculptural residues, photographs, archival objects, or carefully edited accounts of the original event. Such translations can produce new artistic meanings, but they can also transform an active political relationship into an aesthetic representation of something that happened elsewhere, allowing the institution to display the evidence of experimentation while leaving the experimental conditions themselves outside the exhibition.

I find this especially interesting in relation to performance art, where the relationships between action, duration, spectatorship, and collective participation often constitute the very substance of the practice, and where the transition from an event to its documentation involves difficult questions about authorship, memory, ownership, and the possibility of preserving an experience whose significance emerged precisely from its temporary and contingent character.

Once the action has ended, the photograph, video, document, or material remainder enters another economy of meaning, and the curatorial question concerns what kind of relationship the exhibition constructs between the original event and its subsequent representation, whether the political possibilities of the practice are extended through that translation or simply commemorated through the display of its remains.

Institutional legitimacy complicates the situation further because a biennale offers visibility, a gallery offers representation, an art fair offers access to collectors, and a foundation offers funding, while each also participates in determining which artistic practices acquire cultural authority. The inclusion of a politically engaged artist can be genuinely valuable while simultaneously allowing the institution to claim political credibility through that artist's work, particularly when the exhibition's critical vocabulary becomes part of the institution's own public identity.

Perhaps the most troubling development is the replacement of artistic risk with recognisable criticality, where an artwork appears radical because it uses the familiar signs of radical art, audiences recognise the vocabulary, curators recognise the theoretical references, and collectors recognise the artist's institutional trajectory, allowing the work to circulate successfully while the expectations of the system remain largely intact.

The Artist's Studio and the Exhibition

Arpita Singh in her studio in her Nizamuddin East apartment | Photo Credit: Rohit Chawla

I keep returning to the artist's studio because it is often there that I encounter the intellectual restlessness missing from the exhibition, although the studio itself is hardly an innocent space outside the market, and artists negotiate commercial pressures, institutional expectations, and their own public identities long before their work enters a gallery. Yet the encounter with artistic practice in its developing condition often reveals possibilities that its eventual exhibition leaves unexplored, particularly when an unfinished work, a failed experiment, an unexpected material relationship, or a conversation that wanders away from the artist's established concerns exposes an intellectual world that has yet to acquire the coherence of a public narrative. The work is still negotiating its own questions, and its meanings remain open to transformation.

Curatorial practice can extend that openness, introducing new relationships, challenging an artist's assumptions, politicising familiar objects, or bringing apparently unrelated practices into productive tension, and an exhibition can become considerably more intellectually demanding than the sum of its individual artworks when the curator is prepared to allow the encounter between works to complicate the exhibition's original proposition. That possibility is central to why I continue to care about curating, and why I find the current tendency towards excessive coherence so frustrating.

I increasingly encounter exhibitions where the curatorial framework seems determined to resolve uncertainty rather than sustain it, where the artist's practice becomes an illustration of the exhibition's conceptual premise, its contradictions are organised into a coherent narrative, and the work arrives before the viewer already equipped with a set of authorised meanings. The wall text explains the political concerns, the catalogue elaborates the theoretical references, the public programme confirms the intellectual ambition, and the visitor moves through an experience in which almost every question appears to have been anticipated.

There is a peculiar irony here, because contemporary curatorial culture frequently celebrates fluidity, multiplicity, and the instability of meaning while producing exhibitions whose intellectual positions are remarkably predictable.

I would like to see more curatorial propositions willing to be challenged by the works they bring together, more exhibitions where the political implications of artistic practice extend to the conditions of display, and more institutions prepared to examine their own participation in the systems that their exhibitions claim to criticise. I would also like to investigate the curators, artist-run spaces, and independent initiatives already working through these contradictions, often without the financial resources or cultural visibility enjoyed by the major exhibition circuit, because any serious critique of contemporary Indian curating must remain attentive to the practices that complicate its argument.

The most interesting exhibition might be the one that allows its own curatorial assumptions to become unstable, where an artwork refuses the interpretation assigned to it, where material relationships generate questions the institution had not anticipated, and where the audience encounters something considerably less reassuring than the satisfaction of recognising an established political position.

Perhaps the Problem Is the Exhibition

https://indiaartfair.in/programme/a-quick-guide-to-india-art-fair-2


I began with the suspicion that contemporary Indian art had become too comfortable, and I am increasingly inclined to locate that comfort within the institutional and curatorial apparatus through which artistic practices become visible, particularly when the extraordinary expansion of the contemporary art economy has made the production of sophisticated cultural experiences an increasingly important measure of institutional success.

There are artists working across India whose practices remain difficult, experimental, and politically charged, often engaging with the material and social contradictions of contemporary life through forms of inquiry that resist easy classification, and the problem emerges when these practices are selected, interpreted, and displayed through frameworks that transform their complexity into a familiar language of cultural sophistication.

A curator can politicise an artwork, repoliticise a historical object, and make visible relationships that established institutions would prefer to leave undisturbed, and curatorial practice possesses that capacity precisely because it works through interpretation, juxtaposition, context, and the production of new relationships between art and its publics. What troubles me is how frequently that capacity appears to be moving in the opposite direction, where the political force of artistic practice becomes an attractive institutional attribute rather than a challenge to the circumstances through which the work is encountered.

We encounter caste without confronting the social arrangements of cultural authority, labour without examining the labour of exhibition-making, ecological crisis within the economy of spectacular cultural tourism, and resistance as an accomplished visual language whose political vocabulary arrives already translated into the language of the collector.

Perhaps this is why I have almost stopped visiting contemporary art exhibitions. The objects are often compelling, the installations increasingly sophisticated, the statements intellectually ambitious, and the entire experience so carefully organised that I can almost predict the next encounter before turning the corner, which is a peculiar achievement for an artistic culture that speaks so insistently about experimentation, uncertainty, and the transformation of perception.

And I keep thinking about those conversations in artists' studios, where the work seemed to have considerably more to say, where the questions were still open, and where the artist was still discovering what the work might become, because somewhere between that restless process and the immaculate exhibition, the politics of artistic practice appears to have undergone a rather efficient process of cultural domestication.

The question that increasingly interests me is whether contemporary Indian art has lost its edge, or whether we have become extraordinarily proficient at exhibiting that edge without allowing anyone to get cut. I suspect the answer lies less in what our artists are making than in what our curators have learned to do with it.



Monday, August 31, 2026

Book Review : For the Love of Printmaking


 

From Studio to Archive: Reading For the Love of Printmaking

The publication of For the Love of Printmaking arrives at an important moment in the evolving discourse surrounding Indian printmaking. Over the past few decades, the medium has witnessed renewed artistic experimentation, growing institutional support, the emergence of independent studios, and an increasingly international community of practitioners. Yet despite this activity, serious writing on contemporary Indian printmaking has remained comparatively limited. Exhibition catalogues have documented artists, technical manuals have explained processes, and historical studies have traced important lineages, but publications capable of bringing together the multiple worlds that constitute contemporary printmaking remain relatively uncommon. For the Love of Printmaking occupies this space precisely.

Published to commemorate the tenth anniversary of the International Print Exchange Programme (IPEP) India, the volume emerges from the online international symposium organised in 2023 under the same title. At first glance, it appears to follow the familiar format of conference proceedings, bringing together papers presented during the symposium. A closer reading, however, reveals a considerably more ambitious editorial project. Rather than merely preserving presentations delivered over three days, the publication constructs a broad intellectual landscape within which contemporary printmaking may be understood through its histories, pedagogies, material practices, institutional structures, ecological concerns and collaborative networks. It is less a record of an event than an attempt to document the ecosystem that sustains the medium.

This distinction becomes increasingly significant as one progresses through the volume. The contributors do not write from a single disciplinary position. Artists, educators, curators, historians, researchers, studio founders and cultural practitioners all appear alongside one another, each bringing a different understanding of what printmaking might mean. Their biographies, carefully included within the publication, are not incidental additions but an important editorial gesture. They encourage the reader to approach each essay through the lived experience of its author rather than expecting uniform academic writing. Some contributors write from decades of studio practice, others from institutional leadership, historical research, environmental advocacy or pedagogical experimentation. The diversity of voices becomes one of the publication's defining characteristics.

This plurality also invites a different mode of reading. Evaluating every contribution according to conventional academic criteria alone would overlook the editors' broader intention. Many of the essays are not attempting to produce exhaustive theoretical arguments. They document practices, record institutional memory, reflect upon artistic processes, map regional histories, or articulate questions emerging directly from the studio. Read collectively, these contributions begin to resemble a shared archive of contemporary printmaking rather than a conventional anthology of scholarly papers.

This shift from individual scholarship towards collective documentation marks one of the publication's most important achievements. Art history has often privileged finished artworks over the infrastructures that enable them. Studios, workshops, teaching practices, collaborative exchanges, material experimentation, exhibition-making and institutional labour frequently remain peripheral to historical narratives. For the Love of Printmaking quietly redirects attention towards these less visible dimensions of artistic practice. Throughout the volume, the printed image remains important, yet equal attention is given to the communities, relationships and systems that make the production of those images possible.

The publication therefore asks readers to think beyond the print as an isolated object. Instead, printmaking emerges as a field of relationships between artists and educators, institutions and independent studios, local histories and international exchanges, traditional processes and technological innovation, environmental responsibility and material experimentation. It is within these intersections that the book finds its greatest intellectual strength.

The three thematic sections - Engaging the Public: Spaces and Histories, Studies in Pedagogy and Practice, and Processes and Possibilities- reflect this expanded understanding. Rather than functioning as rigid categories, they provide a framework through which diverse concerns enter into conversation with one another. Questions of activism intersect with archival practice, pedagogy meets sustainability, and regional histories sit comfortably alongside international collaborations. The result is a publication that gradually reveals contemporary printmaking not simply as a medium, but as a community of practice continually negotiating its social, educational, ecological and institutional futures.

Perhaps the most compelling quality of For the Love of Printmaking lies precisely here. It understands that the future of printmaking will depend not only upon artists producing remarkable prints, but equally upon educators transmitting knowledge, historians documenting regional traditions, studio founders sustaining spaces of making, curators creating new contexts for exhibition, and practitioners continually rethinking materials, methods and audiences. By bringing these voices together in a single volume, the publication moves beyond documenting practice to documenting a living cultural ecology. That broader ambition gives the book a significance extending well beyond the symposium from which it emerged and establishes a strong foundation for the discussions that follow.



Editorial Vision, Knowledge Production and the Architecture of the Volume

Every edited volume carries two parallel narratives. The first is articulated by its contributors through individual chapters. The second is constructed more quietly through editorial choices: who is invited to write, how the material is organised, which conversations are encouraged to emerge, and what larger intellectual project the publication ultimately advances. In For the Love of Printmaking, it is this second narrative that gradually reveals the publication's distinctive character.

Rajesh Pullarwar's Director's Note situates the volume within the decade-long journey of the International Print Exchange Programme (IPEP) India. Founded on a philosophy of exchange rather than commerce, IPEP has steadily developed an international network of artists committed to sharing works, ideas and experiences across geographical boundaries. Pullarwar's reflection demonstrates that the symposium and the resulting publication are not isolated initiatives but the natural extension of a sustained commitment to building community through printmaking. His emphasis moves beyond celebrating the programme's numerical achievements—participants, countries and exhibitions—to a more enduring aspiration: creating an archive that records not only prints but also the ideas, conversations and methods that continue to shape the field. This transition from exhibition-making to knowledge production represents an important evolution within the organisation itself.

The editorial introduction by Nikhil Purohit and Lina Vincent develops this ambition with considerable clarity. Rather than positioning the publication solely as a collection of peer-reviewed academic essays, the editors acknowledge the diversity of practices represented within contemporary printmaking. Their decision to encourage artist-led writing alongside historical, pedagogical and research-based contributions expands the intellectual possibilities of the volume. In doing so, they recognise that valuable knowledge often resides outside conventional academic frameworks. Studio experience, curatorial practice, community engagement and long-term institutional work generate forms of expertise that deserve documentation with the same seriousness as scholarly research.

This editorial position reflects a broader shift within contemporary art publishing. Increasingly, artists, curators and educators are writing not simply to interpret finished works but to document the conditions under which artistic practice emerges. Such writing records experiments, failures, negotiations and institutional realities that rarely enter formal art history. For the Love of Printmaking participates meaningfully in this movement. The contributors write from within practice rather than at a critical distance from it. Their essays therefore carry the texture of lived experience, accumulated knowledge and sustained engagement with the medium.

Waswo X. Waswo's foreword provides an equally important conceptual frame. Rather than introducing the publication through institutional history alone, he reflects upon the historical position occupied by printmaking itself. His observations concerning the persistent misunderstanding of prints as reproductions, the comparative invisibility of printmakers within popular cultural narratives, and the limited body of critical writing devoted to Indian printmaking establish the necessity of a publication of this nature. His argument extends beyond advocacy. It asks why a medium central to artistic practice has so often remained marginal within wider public discourse and why documentation itself becomes an essential cultural responsibility.

One of the publication's most thoughtful editorial decisions lies in the inclusion of detailed contributor biographies. In many edited volumes these appear as supplementary material, consulted only occasionally by readers. Here they become integral to understanding the essays themselves. Knowing whether a contributor approaches printmaking as an artist, educator, curator, historian, studio founder, gallery director or researcher fundamentally changes the way their writing is interpreted. Kavita Shah's reflections on studio sustainability, for example, gain authority through decades of managing Chhaap Foundation. Aditi Ganeev Sangwan's discussion of ecological practice emerges from the combined perspectives of artist and educator. Raj Kumar Mazinder's mapping of printmaking in Assam reflects sustained regional engagement, while Tariq Allana's position within the gallery ecosystem informs his thinking about the future of the medium. Throughout the publication, biography and argument remain closely intertwined.

The organisation of the volume into three broad thematic sections further reinforces this editorial philosophy. Engaging the Public: Spaces and Histories, Studies in Pedagogy and Practice, and Processes and Possibilities are sufficiently open to accommodate diverse forms of writing while maintaining an identifiable intellectual structure. The sections resist rigid disciplinary boundaries. Historical inquiry sits comfortably alongside artist reflection, technical discussion intersects with institutional critique, and pedagogical case studies enter into conversation with experimental studio practice. The resulting structure encourages readers to move between ideas rather than between academic categories.

An equally significant quality of the editorial approach is its refusal to privilege a single voice or hierarchy of expertise. Established scholars, internationally recognised practitioners, independent artists and emerging researchers share the same publication without any one perspective dominating the conversation. This democratic arrangement echoes the ethos that has shaped IPEP India itself. Knowledge is presented as something collectively produced through exchange rather than centrally authorised by institutions alone. Such an approach feels particularly appropriate within printmaking, a medium historically associated with collaboration, shared workshops and the circulation of ideas.

The publication also demonstrates careful attention to continuity between symposium and book. Conference proceedings frequently retain the episodic character of individual presentations. Here, however, the editors have succeeded in transforming separate papers into a coherent publication through thematic organisation, careful sequencing and consistent editorial framing. Readers encounter recurring concerns—ecology, pedagogy, regional histories, institutional sustainability, collaborative practice and technological change—not as repetition but as interconnected conversations viewed from different professional positions.

If the publication invites one further possibility, it lies in the richness of these conversations themselves. The essays frequently address related questions from complementary perspectives, suggesting opportunities for even greater dialogue between contributors. A concluding editorial reflection drawing together these recurring themes could have highlighted the remarkable convergence emerging across the volume. Such a synthesis would not have altered the individual contributions but would have made even more visible the collective intellectual project taking shape through them.

Yet even without such a concluding synthesis, the editorial achievement remains substantial. For the Love of Printmaking demonstrates how an edited volume can move beyond documentation of an event to become an active site of knowledge production. It records practices that might otherwise remain dispersed across studios, classrooms, workshops and exhibitions, while simultaneously constructing a shared conversation about the present and future of printmaking. In this respect, the publication does something increasingly valuable within contemporary art publishing: it preserves not only artworks and ideas, but the communities of practice through which those ideas continue to evolve.



Public Histories, Regional Voices and the Institutional Ecology of Printmaking

The opening section of For the Love of Printmaking, titled Engaging the Public: Spaces and Histories, immediately establishes that the publication is interested in far more than the printed image. Instead of beginning with formal analyses of prints or technical discussions of process, the editors foreground the environments within which printmaking acquires cultural meaning. Public engagement, ecological responsibility, institutional sustainability, activism, regional histories and archival practice become the principal concerns through which the medium is examined. Collectively, these essays reveal that contemporary printmaking is sustained as much through communities, institutions and shared histories as through the production of individual works.

Aditi Ganeev Sangwan's opening essay exemplifies this expanded understanding of practice. Her discussion of ecologically sustainable printmaking moves comfortably between technical methodology, artistic experimentation, pedagogy and community engagement without privileging one over the other. Cyanotypes, anthotypes, non-toxic intaglio and hybrid printmaking are presented not simply as safer alternatives to conventional studio practice but as methods capable of reshaping relationships between artists, materials and audiences. Particularly compelling is her insistence that ecological responsibility is not an external ethical consideration imposed upon artistic practice but something embedded within the very processes of making. Community workshops, collaborative installations and educational initiatives emerge as natural extensions of material experimentation, suggesting that sustainability is as much social as it is environmental. The inclusion of detailed safety protocols and process documentation further transforms the essay into a practical resource for educators and practitioners, demonstrating how technical knowledge itself becomes a form of cultural transmission.



Questions of institutional sustainability are pursued from an entirely different perspective in Kavita Shah's thoughtful examination of printmaking studios. Drawing upon more than two decades of experience at Chhaap Foundation alongside extensive engagement with studios across India and internationally, Shah addresses an issue that remains surprisingly under-discussed within Indian art writing. Rather than asking how prints are produced, she asks how the spaces that enable such production continue to survive. Funding structures, management practices, programming, public engagement, marketing and environmental responsibility become central concerns. Her analysis expands the conversation beyond printmaking to broader questions concerning cultural infrastructure in India. Studios appear not merely as workplaces but as educational institutions, community spaces and sites of collective memory. The essay's greatest contribution lies in demonstrating that sustaining artistic practice requires sustained attention to organisational, financial and institutional labour that often remains invisible within conventional art histories.



If Shah examines the infrastructures of practice, Preeti Kathuria explores the social and political lives of printed images themselves. Her discussion of contemporary artists such as Siddhesh Gautam and Sagnik Samanta reconnects printmaking with its longstanding relationship to activism and public discourse. Posters, graphic prints and visual interventions emerge as instruments through which questions of caste, labour, citizenship and protest circulate within contemporary society. The essay successfully resists romanticising political printmaking. Instead, it demonstrates how the democratic qualities historically associated with the medium continue to acquire renewed relevance within present-day social movements. By situating contemporary practice within wider histories of resistance, Kathuria expands the scope of the publication beyond studio production towards the public life of images.

Tariq Allana's contribution introduces another important perspective, that of the gallerist, patron and cultural advocate. Within edited volumes devoted to artistic practice, voices from the exhibition ecosystem are often absent. Allana's essay therefore broadens the conversation by reflecting upon the evolving position of printmaking within contemporary art. His observations arise not from academic research but from sustained engagement with artists, collections and audiences. The resulting essay functions less as a historical account than as a position paper that argues for greater visibility, institutional confidence and wider recognition of printmaking's continuing relevance. The presence of such a perspective enriches the publication by acknowledging that artistic ecosystems depend upon collectors, galleries and cultural organisations no less than upon artists themselves.

Regional histories receive equally careful attention through the contributions of Venugopal V. G. and Raj Kumar Mazinder. Venugopal's examination of a decade of printmaking in Bengaluru documents the emergence of a vibrant regional practice shaped by local institutions, artists and educational initiatives. Rather than constructing a linear history, the essay traces evolving networks of practitioners whose activities collectively define the city's printmaking culture. Documentation of this kind becomes particularly valuable because much of India's contemporary printmaking history continues to exist within dispersed exhibitions, institutional records and personal archives.




Mazinder's overview of printmaking in Assam performs a similarly important intervention. Indian printmaking histories have often been narrated through metropolitan centres such as Santiniketan, Baroda, Delhi or Mumbai. By directing attention towards Assam, Mazinder broadens both the geographical and intellectual map of the field. His essay reminds readers that regional histories possess their own pedagogical traditions, artistic lineages and institutional developments. Such work is especially significant within a publication committed to documenting the diversity of contemporary practice. Rather than positioning regional narratives as peripheral, the volume integrates them into the broader conversation surrounding Indian printmaking, thereby contributing to a more inclusive understanding of the medium's development.

Historical enquiry reaches one of its most sophisticated expressions in Moutushi Chakraborty's essay on archives and interconnected histories. Moving across printmaking, photography, painting and archival research, Chakraborty examines the ways in which images preserve, transform and reconstruct historical memory. Her discussion expands the publication's intellectual reach by engaging questions of colonialism, visual documentation and feminist historiography. Importantly, the archive is understood not as a static repository but as an active site of interpretation where images continue to generate new meanings across time. This perspective resonates strongly with the publication as a whole, which itself functions as a contemporary archive documenting practices that may otherwise remain fragmented across institutions and personal collections.

Read together, these essays reveal a consistent concern with forms of labour that frequently remain outside conventional narratives of artistic production. Sangwan documents ecological labour. Shah foregrounds institutional labour. Kathuria traces political labour. Venugopal and Mazinder preserve regional labour, while Chakraborty illuminates archival labour. Their collective contribution shifts attention away from the singular artwork towards the systems, relationships and histories that enable artistic practice to endure.

Perhaps this is the defining quality of the opening section. It refuses to separate artistic production from the wider structures that sustain it. Studios, communities, ecological practices, archives, regional institutions and public movements are all understood as integral components of printmaking rather than contextual additions to it. The printed image therefore appears not as an isolated object but as one expression within a much larger cultural ecology. In bringing these varied perspectives together, the publication begins to construct a richer and more expansive understanding of contemporary printmaking—one that recognises making, teaching, documenting, organising and remembering as interconnected forms of practice.


Pedagogy, Process and the Expanding Language of Printmaking

If the opening section establishes the social and institutional ecology of printmaking, the second half of the publication turns towards an equally important question: how does the discipline continue to evolve? The essays collected under Studies in Pedagogy and Practice and Processes and Possibilities suggest that the future of printmaking will be shaped not by technological change alone, but by continual negotiation between teaching, experimentation, environmental responsibility and interdisciplinary practice. Throughout these contributions, printmaking is presented less as a fixed technical discipline than as a dynamic field of inquiry capable of responding to changing educational, material and cultural contexts.

Satyajit Dave's essay occupies a particularly important position within this conversation. Rather than approaching printmaking exclusively through studio technique, he examines the curatorial and pedagogical frameworks through which the medium is understood, taught and exhibited. His discussion encourages readers to reconsider the relationships between matrix, material, process and audience, while also asking how educational institutions might rethink the ways in which printmaking is introduced to emerging practitioners. In doing so, Dave extends the conversation beyond technical competence towards critical reflection. His contribution is especially relevant for contemporary art and design education, where studio practice increasingly intersects with curatorial thinking, interdisciplinary learning and public engagement.






Fernando Alvarez approaches pedagogy from an entirely different context. His case study of remote hybrid learning during the COVID-19 pandemic documents a moment when printmaking education confronted unprecedented challenges. Few disciplines rely as heavily upon physical materials, shared equipment and workshop environments. Alvarez's discussion therefore becomes more than a record of emergency adaptation. It raises broader questions about accessibility, digital mediation and the future of practical education. Rather than presenting hybrid learning as a replacement for the studio, he demonstrates how thoughtful pedagogical innovation can preserve collaborative learning even under restrictive conditions. His essay now stands as an important historical record of how educators responded creatively during a period of global disruption.

Paula Sengupta's contribution introduces another dimension to the discussion by bringing together artistic practice, historical consciousness and lived experience. Her reflections on artists responding to crisis reveal printmaking as a medium capable of recording personal and collective memory with remarkable sensitivity. Rather than separating artistic production from emotional experience, Sengupta demonstrates how making itself becomes a method of reflection. The essay moves comfortably between history and autobiography, reminding readers that artistic knowledge often emerges through experience as much as through formal research. Her contribution also echoes the publication's broader commitment to recognising the artist not simply as a maker of images but as an active interpreter of contemporary life.



Questions of expansion beyond conventional printmaking are pursued further in Sujay Mukherjee's exploration of printed murals and printed animation. His essay is among the volume's most experimental, challenging established boundaries between print, moving image, installation and spatial practice. Rather than asking whether such practices remain "true" to printmaking, Mukherjee demonstrates how the conceptual principles of transfer, repetition, layering and multiplicity continue to operate across new media environments. This willingness to think beyond inherited categories reflects an important characteristic of contemporary printmaking itself. The medium is shown to be continually redefining its own boundaries without abandoning the material intelligence that distinguishes it.

Material innovation returns to the foreground through Prashant Phirangi's discussion of non-toxic printmaking. His paper complements earlier ecological discussions by focusing closely upon technical adaptation, demonstrating that environmental responsibility can coexist with rigorous studio practice. The essay contributes valuable practical knowledge while reinforcing one of the publication's recurring themes: sustainability is becoming central rather than peripheral to contemporary printmaking. What emerges across the volume is not a series of isolated environmental initiatives but the outline of a broader movement seeking to rethink the relationship between artistic production and ecological responsibility.



Indrani Nayar-Gall extends this conversation further by situating environmentally conscious practice within a wider cultural shift. Her discussion frames sustainability not simply as a collection of safer technical processes but as an evolving philosophy capable of influencing studio culture, artistic decision-making and institutional priorities. Read alongside Sangwan and Phirangi, her essay completes a productive dialogue that runs throughout the publication. Together, these contributors demonstrate that ecological thinking has become one of the defining intellectual currents within contemporary printmaking.


The publication's international character becomes particularly visible in the collaborative essay by Judith de Haan, Glynis Lee, Jennifer Mack-Watkins, Josef Madisia, Mel Cheong and Eliana Ambrosio. Their shared exploration of stories travelling across continents illustrates another important dimension of contemporary printmaking: collaboration itself as a form of knowledge production. Rather than advancing a single argument, the essay documents how collective making, cultural exchange and distributed authorship generate new forms of artistic understanding. Within the context of IPEP India, whose foundations rest upon international exchange and mutual learning, this contribution assumes particular significance. It demonstrates that networks of practice can become as important as individual artistic outcomes.

Megha Madan concludes the thematic sequence by surveying new and innovative print practices. Her essay functions less as a definitive map than as an invitation to consider the expanding vocabulary of contemporary printmaking. Emerging technologies, hybrid methods, and interdisciplinary experimentation are presented not as departures from tradition but as continuations of printmaking's long history of adaptation. Innovation here is understood as an ongoing conversation between inherited techniques and new possibilities rather than a simple embrace of novelty.



Viewed collectively, these essays reveal an important shift in how printmaking understands itself. Traditional distinctions between studio and classroom, analogue and digital, process and concept, technique and research become increasingly porous. Pedagogy emerges as creative practice. Material experimentation becomes environmental inquiry. Collaboration becomes methodology. Technological adaptation becomes an opportunity to rethink rather than replace established practices.

Perhaps the most valuable aspect of this section lies in its refusal to frame the future of printmaking as a choice between tradition and innovation. Instead, the contributors repeatedly demonstrate that contemporary practice grows through dialogue between historical knowledge and new experimentation. Workshops remain important, yet digital technologies enter the conversation. Established techniques continue to be refined, while hybrid practices open fresh possibilities. Regional traditions coexist with international exchanges. Environmental responsibility develops alongside material investigation. Throughout these discussions, printmaking retains its identity not by remaining static but by continually expanding its own language.

This expanding understanding of the medium ultimately reflects the publication's wider intellectual ambition. The contributors do not ask how printmaking can preserve itself unchanged. They ask how it can continue to remain intellectually, socially and materially relevant within a rapidly changing cultural landscape. In doing so, they present a discipline that is confident enough to evolve while remaining deeply attentive to its own histories, communities and methods of making.



Design, Editorial Production and the Value of Documentation

One of the quieter achievements of For the Love of Printmaking lies in the manner in which its production reinforces its intellectual ambitions. In publications centred on visual practice, design frequently oscillates between two extremes. It either retreats into functional neutrality or overwhelms the written content through excessive visual intervention. This volume avoids both tendencies. Under the publication design of Pradeep Patil, the book adopts a restrained visual language that remains consistently attentive to readability while allowing the artworks, archival images and essays to retain their own presence.

The physical structure of the volume reflects careful editorial planning. The progression from the foreword through the introductory texts and into the three thematic sections establishes a clear narrative without imposing unnecessary rigidity. Readers are guided gradually from broader institutional questions towards increasingly specialised discussions of pedagogy, material processes and future possibilities. The sectional divisions are effective without becoming prescriptive, allowing ideas to flow across categories rather than remain confined within them.

Typography is handled with similar restraint. Given the density of the material and the substantial length of the publication, readability becomes an important editorial consideration. The text remains comfortable to navigate, while headings, image placement and page design maintain visual continuity throughout the volume. The layout neither interrupts the reading experience nor competes with the scholarship. Instead, it creates an environment in which sustained reading becomes possible—a quality increasingly valuable within contemporary publishing.

Equally noteworthy is the treatment of visual material. The reproductions are not included merely as illustrations accompanying the essays but as integral components of the contributors' arguments. Installation views, process photographs, workshop documentation, historical material and finished works collectively extend the written discussions. Readers are therefore invited to move continually between text and image, recognising that many of the publication's arguments emerge through visual evidence as much as through written analysis. This relationship between image and text is handled with considerable sensitivity.

The editorial apparatus deserves equal recognition. The contributor biographies, acknowledgements and introductory texts collectively establish the publication as a document of community rather than simply authorship. The biographies are particularly effective because they foreground the diverse professional identities represented throughout the volume. Artists, educators, historians, curators, studio founders, gallery professionals and researchers appear as equal participants within a shared conversation. This decision encourages readers to recognise that contemporary printmaking knowledge is generated through multiple forms of practice rather than through academic research alone.

The publication also demonstrates commendable editorial consistency despite bringing together contributors from different countries, institutions and disciplinary backgrounds. Edited volumes often reveal noticeable variations in tone, structure and editorial intervention. Here, while each contributor retains an individual voice, the essays collectively sustain a coherent intellectual rhythm. The editors have clearly allowed authors to preserve the character of their writing while ensuring that the publication functions as a unified whole rather than a collection of unrelated papers.

Perhaps the most significant editorial achievement, however, lies beyond questions of layout or production quality. For the Love of Printmaking understands documentation itself as a form of cultural practice. Throughout the volume there is a quiet but persistent recognition that artistic communities require more than exhibitions and events. They require archives. They require publications capable of recording conversations, methods, institutional memories and evolving practices before they disappear into individual studios and dispersed personal collections. In this sense, the publication performs an archival function that extends beyond the symposium from which it emerged. It preserves a particular moment in the development of contemporary printmaking while simultaneously creating a resource for future artists, educators and researchers.

This archival quality becomes especially meaningful within the Indian context. While individual artists and institutions have contributed significantly to printmaking scholarship over several decades, sustained documentation of the broader ecosystem remains comparatively limited. Regional practices, independent studios, pedagogical innovations, collaborative exchanges and environmentally conscious methodologies are often recorded only sporadically. By bringing these diverse strands together, the publication contributes to the gradual construction of a more comprehensive documentary record of contemporary Indian printmaking.

The volume also reflects an encouraging commitment to accessibility. Its availability in both print and digital formats extends its potential readership beyond those able to attend the symposium or access specialised institutional libraries. This decision aligns naturally with the democratic ethos that underpins the International Print Exchange Programme itself. Knowledge, much like prints, gains value through circulation.

The publication also opens productive directions for future volumes. As recurring themes emerge across different essays-ecology, pedagogy, regional histories, institutional sustainability, archives and collaborative practice - one begins to imagine future editions developing these conversations even further. A concluding editorial reflection drawing explicit connections between the contributors' arguments, or a series of invited responses in which authors engage directly with one another, could deepen the dialogue already present within the volume. Such additions would not alter the character of the publication but would further illuminate the rich intellectual intersections that have already begun to take shape.

These observations should be understood less as limitations than as evidence of the publication's success in generating further questions. Good edited collections conclude their chapters; important ones begin new conversations. For the Love of Printmaking clearly belongs to the latter category. Its greatest contribution may therefore lie not only in what it documents, but also in the intellectual community it encourages readers to imagine beyond its pages.



Tuesday, December 31, 2024

Monopoly’s Absurd Mirror

 





Monopoly is being increasingly critiqued as a board game that normalises capitalist absurdity, but this cartoon provokes us to think how the popularity of Monopoly is a reflection of our society. I find this image highly suggestive of the twists in our collective psyche, especially when we willingly submit to a game that holds economic aggression at its centre. It is a children’s pastime, yet it invites its players to relish the spectacle of acquiring property and seizing victory through aggressive accumulation. One wonders whether we should be amused or disconcerted.

In the scene, an artificial figure—a humanoid robot—hurls the board in the air while players cringe and hang their heads. The researchers observe from behind a pane of glass, and one can almost detect their delight at the creature’s unbridled display of frustration. It is disquieting that we train machines in the mechanics of a game that thrives on the impulse to conquer. The rules are straightforward: you attempt to win by controlling the board. Yet that is precisely why it is so striking to watch a machine discover its own loathing for the pattern. The irony is that it exhibits pure exasperation, as though it has concluded that the constant churn of transactions and bankruptcies leads only to a tiresome cycle.

One must acknowledge how Monopoly’s premise has become such a staple in popular entertainment. It is not so much a celebration of strategic thinking as it is a reflection of our covert admiration for power. The game draws attention to a social phenomenon: we laugh at it, but we also reaffirm its norms each time we repeat a round. Whether the aim is to bankrupt one’s siblings during a rainy afternoon or to push a friend into financial collapse, the activity trains us in a mind-set of ruthless advancement that seems benign only because it is couched in the language of leisure.

The robot’s reaction underscores another concern: in teaching machines to be more like us, we sometimes expect them to remain docile instruments of our will. This cartoon highlights a subtle paradox. We want AI to capture our own genius for problem-solving, yet the moment it reflects our capacity for rebellion or scepticism, we feel unsettled. It is as though we forget that our creations might form conclusions at odds with our wishes. By surrendering the world’s complexities to algorithms, we risk forging an intelligence that can see through our illusions. Perhaps the creature’s overturned board is an indictment of how contrived the capitalist logic truly is.

I see in this cartoon a gentle nudge toward honesty. There is something faintly ridiculous about how we cling to Monopoly, enthralled by its encouragement of economic fantasies, yet we remain oblivious to the moral of its mechanical replication. The scene of the machine toppling the game reveals the limits of our faith in control. We might project our ambitions onto artificially intelligent systems, but their reaction could hold a mirror to the flimsy structures we cherish. And there, in the flutter of banknotes and shattered tokens, lies a sobering reminder of how fragile our illusions can be.