,
I have almost stopped looking at contemporary art. A rather embarrassing admission for someone who has spent a substantial part of his life looking at art, writing about it, working with artists, and occasionally curating exhibitions, but I increasingly find myself walking through galleries, museums, art fairs, and biennales with a peculiar sense of intellectual exhaustion, surrounded by impeccably installed objects, elaborate curatorial propositions, and the reassuring vocabulary of political engagement, while struggling to remain interested in what is being presented. Contemporary art exhibitions have begun to put me to sleep, which is especially unfortunate considering how much extraordinary artistic work continues to be produced across India, and how enthusiastically our cultural institutions insist that we are living through a moment of unprecedented artistic experimentation.
And just when I thought contemporary Indian art had exhausted its capacity to surprise me, Karan Johar was announced as the Cultural Ambassador of Art Mumbai 2026. I must admit, I laughed. The man who has spent decades perfecting the aesthetics of aspiration, glamour, and spectacular consumption had arrived to represent an art world that spends an extraordinary amount of time discussing resistance, marginality, and the politics of representation. Perhaps the appointment was more intellectually revealing than the organisers intended. We have reached a curious moment when contemporary art can speak endlessly about dismantling structures of power while becoming increasingly comfortable within the machinery of celebrity and luxury. Johar, at least, has always been rather candid about the spectacle he produces.
And perhaps that is precisely what has been troubling me. I have encountered artists in their studios whose practices are far more complicated, unpredictable, and politically charged than their public exhibitions suggest, where an unfinished experiment, a material accident, an unresolved question, or a conversation that wanders unexpectedly into the politics of everyday life can reveal an intellectual world considerably richer than the one eventually presented to the public. Yet somewhere between the studio and the gallery, something peculiar happens. The work acquires an extraordinarily coherent narrative, its contradictions are carefully organised, its political urgency is transformed into an elegant visual proposition, and the artist's restless engagement with the world becomes a perfectly articulated curatorial statement.
The politics remains in the vocabulary, but discomfort disappears from the encounter.
The Curious Business of Making Dissent Comfortable
![]() |
| Birender Yadav with Only the Earth Knows Their Labour at the Kochi Muziris Biennale (Kochi Biennale Foundation) |
Everything appears to be in place. The appropriate theoretical references, the material sophistication, the politically conscious language, the reassuring suggestion that we are encountering something urgent, and yet the urgency has somehow evaporated, leaving behind an exhibition that knows exactly how to look critical without necessarily producing a critical encounter.
I find myself increasingly interested in the distinction between what the artwork actually does, what the artist intends, what the curator proposes, what the institution permits, and what the collector eventually takes home, because these are different moments in the cultural life of an artwork, and the relationships between them deserve considerably more attention than they usually receive. The artwork might emerge from a difficult engagement with social reality, but its institutional presentation can reorganise that engagement into something more coherent, more recognisable, and considerably easier to consume.
I would also resist the temptation to equate decoration with intellectual weakness, particularly in a country where textiles, ornament, miniature painting, ritual objects, and vernacular visual cultures have carried extraordinarily complicated histories of labour, knowledge, and political representation. The decorative has its own intellectual traditions, and the modernist suspicion of ornament has already produced enough distortions in the writing of Indian art history. What troubles me is something more specific: the conversion of artistic complexity into easily consumable cultural sophistication, where even an aggressively political artwork can become a decorative confirmation of the viewer's existing intellectual and moral position.
The Curatorial Imagination and the Politics of Interpretation
![]() |
| Shailesh B.R. | New Moon NSIC Exhibition Grounds, Okhla, New Delhi, 5 - 8 February 2026| Vadhera Art Gallery |
Which makes the current situation all the more disappointing, because I am increasingly encountering the opposite process. Rather than politicising the work, curatorial practice seems remarkably adept at depoliticising it, even while retaining the language of political engagement, so that the exhibition acknowledges the artist's concerns, identifies the appropriate historical references, translates the work into an intellectually respectable proposition, and quietly abandons the relationships that might make the work genuinely uncomfortable.
This is a curious kind of depoliticisation because it rarely requires the removal of political content. The political content remains conspicuously present, sometimes becoming the exhibition's principal attraction, while the relationships between that content and the conditions through which it is encountered remain conveniently unexplored. An artwork concerned with labour becomes an elegant installation, while the labour involved in producing the exhibition remains invisible; a work investigating caste becomes part of a prestigious institutional programme without necessarily prompting an examination of the social organisation of cultural authority; an ecological intervention becomes a centrepiece of cultural tourism, its critique of extraction absorbed into the spectacle of the event itself.
The curator has the capacity to expose these contradictions, to make them central to the exhibition, and to complicate the audience's relationship with the institution, but when curatorial practice instead resolves them into a coherent and comfortable narrative, something politically significant is lost.
![]() |
| . Prabhakar Kamble — Babasaheb with Labours (2022)| India Art Fair |
The situation becomes more complicated as the boundaries between curatorial practice, gallery representation, and commercial mediation grow increasingly blurred, particularly when the same institution selects the artists, determines their public representation, constructs the interpretative framework, negotiates their commercial circulation, and claims curatorial authority over the resulting exhibition. Commercial galleries have produced intellectually significant exhibitions, and several Indian galleries have supported difficult artistic practices for decades, but the overlap between curatorial interpretation and commercial interest deserves closer scrutiny when the politics of an artwork must also accommodate the conditions through which that artwork becomes desirable, collectable, and institutionally prestigious.
The question concerns what happens to interpretation when the curator becomes increasingly responsible for producing a coherent cultural experience, rather than allowing the work to generate difficult and sometimes contradictory relationships with the world around it.
The Biennale and Its Contradictions
![]() |
| Biraaj Dodiya — DOOM ORGAN (2025), ASPINWALL HOUSE, KOCHI-MUZIRIS BIENNALE (KMB) 2025-26 |
The Kochi-Muziris Biennale offers a particularly interesting opportunity to examine these questions because its emergence transformed the geography of contemporary Indian art, creating an international exhibition platform outside the familiar metropolitan centres of Delhi and Mumbai while bringing artistic practices into dialogue with the layered histories, architecture, and material conditions of Kochi. Its sixth edition, For the Time Being, brought together artists and collectives through a curatorial framework concerned with temporality, collective experience, and forms of artistic engagement extending beyond the conventional exhibition object, propositions that have considerable intellectual possibilities in a country where artistic practices have long moved between formal institutions, public space, collective activity, and the social circumstances of everyday life.
Artists such as Birender Yadav and Prabhakar Kamble complicate any suggestion that contemporary Indian art has stopped producing politically engaged or intellectually challenging work, because their practices emerge from sustained engagements with the material and social conditions of Indian life rather than from the convenient adoption of a fashionable critical vocabulary. Yadav's investigations into brick-kiln labour, migrant workers, and the material economies of construction raise questions about extraction, embodied knowledge, and the labour that produces the architecture of contemporary prosperity, while Kamble's engagement with caste, everyday objects, labour, and Ambedkarite thought asks difficult questions about who produces cultural meaning and whose experiences remain invisible within established systems of representation.
Yet these practices also bring me back to the question that interests me most. What happens when an artwork about the invisibility of labour becomes an attraction within a large cultural event whose own labour arrangements, production economies, and institutional hierarchies deserve scrutiny, and how might the exhibition make those relationships visible rather than allowing the artwork's political concerns to remain safely contained within its curatorial description?
The contradiction requires investigation through the actual conditions of exhibition-making, because the presence of political art does not automatically produce a politically engaged exhibition, just as the presence of an ambitious curatorial statement does not guarantee that the resulting encounters will be intellectually demanding. A biennale can create genuinely new forms of artistic participation while also reproducing institutional hierarchies, and a politically ambitious curatorial proposition can produce encounters whose implications exceed the intentions of the curator, which is precisely why the distance between an artist's practice and its institutional presentation deserves to be examined rather than resolved through convenient generalisations.
I find myself wondering whether the spectacular expansion of the biennale as a cultural format has also produced a peculiar expectation that political engagement must become publicly visible through increasingly elaborate exhibition experiences, where the scale of the installation, the sophistication of the curatorial language, and the historical significance of the venue begin to compete with the questions that originally animated the work.
The artwork becomes part of an event, the event becomes part of a city's cultural identity, and the city's cultural identity becomes part of an economy of tourism, patronage, and international recognition, while the political concerns of the artist continue to circulate through the exhibition's publicity as evidence of its intellectual seriousness.
The Expanding Economy of Cultural Sophistication
![]() |
| Shiraz Bayjoo — Sa Sime Lamer (2025), Aspinwall House, Kochi-Muziris Biennale |
There is more money, more professionalisation, more elaborate exhibition-making, and greater international participation, but whether this expansion has produced a corresponding growth in curatorial independence and intellectual risk is another question altogether.
The collector's drawing room has always influenced artistic production, and the relationship between patronage and art has never been innocent, but I am increasingly interested in whether contemporary curatorial practice has begun to internalise the expectations of that drawing room even when its intellectual language continues to insist upon radicality, experimentation, and political engagement. The artwork must remain sufficiently challenging to acquire cultural distinction, sufficiently legible to circulate through institutional narratives, and sufficiently desirable to enter collections, producing a peculiar negotiation in which the appearance of intellectual difficulty can become an important part of its commercial attraction.
This is particularly interesting in relation to the established galleries that have shaped contemporary Indian art, including Nature Morte, Chemould Prescott Road, Sakshi, Gallery Espace, Experimenter, and Project 88, whose histories include substantial contributions to the development and international visibility of artistic practices that might otherwise have remained marginal. Their different trajectories deserve careful attention, because the relationship between commercial representation and curatorial ambition is considerably more complicated than a simple accusation of market corruption, and some of the most intellectually adventurous exhibitions in India have emerged from precisely these spaces.
Yet I would like to examine how individual practices are selected, edited, interpreted, and presented within such institutions, particularly when an artist's larger body of work contains contradictions, experiments, and unresolved questions that do not necessarily fit the coherent identity through which the artist becomes publicly recognisable. Which works become prominent, which aspects of the practice are repeatedly emphasised, which material experiments disappear from the exhibition, and how does the curatorial narrative begin to shape what audiences and collectors understand the artist to represent?
The emerging biennale circuit raises related questions through different institutional arrangements, particularly when exhibitions claim to engage with ecological materials, indigenous knowledge, local communities, and forms of cultural participation outside conventional metropolitan structures. Such commitments deserve serious attention, but so do the relationships through which they are realised, including who controls the interpretation of local knowledge, how the benefits of cultural participation are distributed, and what remains with communities after the exhibition has concluded and the international cultural audience has moved elsewhere.
I am particularly suspicious of the ease with which terms such as community, participation, and decoloniality can enter curatorial language without requiring institutions to examine their own authority over the people, materials, and histories they represent.
The politics of an exhibition cannot be assessed solely through the subjects it represents. Its relationships with people, materials, institutions, and economies are equally significant, and the failure to examine those relationships allows the exhibition to claim political seriousness while remaining remarkably insulated from the implications of its own propositions.
The Aestheticisation of Dissent
![]() |
| Sanchayan Ghosh | A Site for the Pedagogy of Resistance | Install view | Drawn from Practice II | Experimenter – Ballygunge Place, Kolkata | April 14 – June 30, 2022 |
Every one of these strategies can produce extraordinary art, and many have substantial histories of experimentation and resistance, yet their repetition can also make them reassuringly familiar, particularly when the exhibition supplies an interpretative framework that confirms what the viewer already expects to discover.
The experienced visitor enters the gallery already knowing how to read its politics. The curator supplies the appropriate vocabulary, the installation confirms the proposition, and the audience experiences the satisfaction of having encountered something politically significant, even when the encounter has done relatively little to complicate its understanding of the world.
The professionalisation of curatorial language contributes to this process, particularly through the circulation of terms such as liminality, resilience, belonging, memory, ecology, and decoloniality, each carrying legitimate intellectual histories but increasingly capable of describing dozens of materially and politically distinct artistic practices with almost interchangeable results. When the same vocabulary can travel so effortlessly between exhibitions, artists, and institutions, I begin to wonder whether the writing is actually interpreting the work or merely locating it within an already established economy of cultural sophistication.
I have nothing against theory, and would prefer considerably more rigorous theoretical engagement in contemporary Indian art, but the substitution of theoretical vocabulary for theoretical work has become an exhausting habit, where the presence of an intellectual reference is treated as sufficient evidence that an exhibition has undertaken the difficult labour of thinking through its implications.
Another process concerns the domestication of conceptual and process-based art, particularly when an artwork begins as an intervention into public life, a collective experiment, an extended performance, or a process of social inquiry, and subsequently enters the gallery through its documentation, sculptural residues, photographs, archival objects, or carefully edited accounts of the original event. Such translations can produce new artistic meanings, but they can also transform an active political relationship into an aesthetic representation of something that happened elsewhere, allowing the institution to display the evidence of experimentation while leaving the experimental conditions themselves outside the exhibition.
I find this especially interesting in relation to performance art, where the relationships between action, duration, spectatorship, and collective participation often constitute the very substance of the practice, and where the transition from an event to its documentation involves difficult questions about authorship, memory, ownership, and the possibility of preserving an experience whose significance emerged precisely from its temporary and contingent character.
Once the action has ended, the photograph, video, document, or material remainder enters another economy of meaning, and the curatorial question concerns what kind of relationship the exhibition constructs between the original event and its subsequent representation, whether the political possibilities of the practice are extended through that translation or simply commemorated through the display of its remains.
Institutional legitimacy complicates the situation further because a biennale offers visibility, a gallery offers representation, an art fair offers access to collectors, and a foundation offers funding, while each also participates in determining which artistic practices acquire cultural authority. The inclusion of a politically engaged artist can be genuinely valuable while simultaneously allowing the institution to claim political credibility through that artist's work, particularly when the exhibition's critical vocabulary becomes part of the institution's own public identity.
Perhaps the most troubling development is the replacement of artistic risk with recognisable criticality, where an artwork appears radical because it uses the familiar signs of radical art, audiences recognise the vocabulary, curators recognise the theoretical references, and collectors recognise the artist's institutional trajectory, allowing the work to circulate successfully while the expectations of the system remain largely intact.
The Artist's Studio and the Exhibition
Curatorial practice can extend that openness, introducing new relationships, challenging an artist's assumptions, politicising familiar objects, or bringing apparently unrelated practices into productive tension, and an exhibition can become considerably more intellectually demanding than the sum of its individual artworks when the curator is prepared to allow the encounter between works to complicate the exhibition's original proposition. That possibility is central to why I continue to care about curating, and why I find the current tendency towards excessive coherence so frustrating.
I increasingly encounter exhibitions where the curatorial framework seems determined to resolve uncertainty rather than sustain it, where the artist's practice becomes an illustration of the exhibition's conceptual premise, its contradictions are organised into a coherent narrative, and the work arrives before the viewer already equipped with a set of authorised meanings. The wall text explains the political concerns, the catalogue elaborates the theoretical references, the public programme confirms the intellectual ambition, and the visitor moves through an experience in which almost every question appears to have been anticipated.
There is a peculiar irony here, because contemporary curatorial culture frequently celebrates fluidity, multiplicity, and the instability of meaning while producing exhibitions whose intellectual positions are remarkably predictable.
I would like to see more curatorial propositions willing to be challenged by the works they bring together, more exhibitions where the political implications of artistic practice extend to the conditions of display, and more institutions prepared to examine their own participation in the systems that their exhibitions claim to criticise. I would also like to investigate the curators, artist-run spaces, and independent initiatives already working through these contradictions, often without the financial resources or cultural visibility enjoyed by the major exhibition circuit, because any serious critique of contemporary Indian curating must remain attentive to the practices that complicate its argument.
The most interesting exhibition might be the one that allows its own curatorial assumptions to become unstable, where an artwork refuses the interpretation assigned to it, where material relationships generate questions the institution had not anticipated, and where the audience encounters something considerably less reassuring than the satisfaction of recognising an established political position.
Perhaps the Problem Is the Exhibition
![]() |
| https://indiaartfair.in/programme/a-quick-guide-to-india-art-fair-2 |
I began with the suspicion that contemporary Indian art had become too comfortable, and I am increasingly inclined to locate that comfort within the institutional and curatorial apparatus through which artistic practices become visible, particularly when the extraordinary expansion of the contemporary art economy has made the production of sophisticated cultural experiences an increasingly important measure of institutional success.
There are artists working across India whose practices remain difficult, experimental, and politically charged, often engaging with the material and social contradictions of contemporary life through forms of inquiry that resist easy classification, and the problem emerges when these practices are selected, interpreted, and displayed through frameworks that transform their complexity into a familiar language of cultural sophistication.
A curator can politicise an artwork, repoliticise a historical object, and make visible relationships that established institutions would prefer to leave undisturbed, and curatorial practice possesses that capacity precisely because it works through interpretation, juxtaposition, context, and the production of new relationships between art and its publics. What troubles me is how frequently that capacity appears to be moving in the opposite direction, where the political force of artistic practice becomes an attractive institutional attribute rather than a challenge to the circumstances through which the work is encountered.
We encounter caste without confronting the social arrangements of cultural authority, labour without examining the labour of exhibition-making, ecological crisis within the economy of spectacular cultural tourism, and resistance as an accomplished visual language whose political vocabulary arrives already translated into the language of the collector.
Perhaps this is why I have almost stopped visiting contemporary art exhibitions. The objects are often compelling, the installations increasingly sophisticated, the statements intellectually ambitious, and the entire experience so carefully organised that I can almost predict the next encounter before turning the corner, which is a peculiar achievement for an artistic culture that speaks so insistently about experimentation, uncertainty, and the transformation of perception.
And I keep thinking about those conversations in artists' studios, where the work seemed to have considerably more to say, where the questions were still open, and where the artist was still discovering what the work might become, because somewhere between that restless process and the immaculate exhibition, the politics of artistic practice appears to have undergone a rather efficient process of cultural domestication.
The question that increasingly interests me is whether contemporary Indian art has lost its edge, or whether we have become extraordinarily proficient at exhibiting that edge without allowing anyone to get cut. I suspect the answer lies less in what our artists are making than in what our curators have learned to do with it.









.png)

